Pizza a'fetta strives to exceed your expectations delivering exceptional quality food and customer service. Rated as one of top 50 pizzerias in the US by Pizza Today Magazine.
About Pizza a Fetta
Reviews & Ratings
-
September 21, 2026ralphbrier55Big Disappointment
I never like to leave a bad review unless it’s absolutely necessary. It’s necessary. We bought a pizza. It wasn’t good. Overloaded with tomato paste(tasteless). The ingredients were all poor quality. The pizza crust was bland, tasteless and soggy. It was wet too to bottom. A complete waste of $$$. We ate 2 pieces and threw it out. Possibly the worst pizza we have ever had. We had high hopes but alas…they couldn’t make it happen. Go somewhere else. It’s like they gave up on the real craft long ago if they ever had it!
-
September 12, 2026Smiles4milesPizza Perfection
Fantastic pizza! You can order some varieties by the slice but the gourmet pizzas are out of this world. The crust and sauce are so flavorful and delicious, absolutely yummy. The restaurant is small and you may have a wait for your pie but hang in there. Pizza A’Fetta is on the north end of Hemlock, with indoor and outdoor seating.
-
August 21, 2026Keikibird
Delicious!
Pizza is a little too cheesy but delicious!
-
August 11, 2026MeegsmanExcellent
Decided this was a must-try based on reviews and were not disappointed. Both our salad and crab pizza were excellent. Takeout was on time and easily picked up. The top 50 claim may just be accurate.
-
January 18, 2026Melissa H
Disappointing Service
We showed up 45minutes before closing for pizza by the slice. First two workers who saw us flat out ignored us. When a third showed up, he seems annoyed as he told us that they didn’t have any pizza by the slice left and that we would need to order a whole pizza. They were clearly trying to close up early. Disappointing as we don’t live locally and my husband loves this spot.