Martolli’s uses only the freshest ingredients, and they prepare their dough and sauces fresh daily. Pizzas are hand-tossed in the traditional way and baked in old fashioned slate ovens. Visit the restaurant’s website for complete menu.
About Martolli’s Authentic Hand Tossed Pizza
Reviews & Ratings
-
August 17, 2025Quest14098581020Fantastic pizza
This pizza was amazing, from the crust, to the sauce, to the topping! We ordered a half & half (sometimes hard to cook evenly) both sides were perfect. I highly recommend & we will return next time we are in town.
-
January 3, 2025Ben VGood pizza, mediocre service.
Good pizza, medium service. Tried to call in an order but were asked to hold. We sat on hold for ten minutes - I think we were probably forgotten about. We hung up as we pulled up to the restaurant and there was no orders in progress nor any other customers. Just three staff happily chatting. Pizza was pretty good though.
-
September 1, 2022PAHWestfieldGood slice
Great little spot to grab a quick slice if you are in a hurry. They have slices ready to go and also made to order pizzas. Fresh ingredients and made from scratch.
-
August 25, 2021Chuck2010
Okay for Take Out Pizza
Needed a later evening dinner choice as they were not too many options in Sisters. Pizza place was very busy due to lack of choices to eat. Simple cheese Pizza was pretty good.
-
July 6, 2021EdwardsG8
Pizza & can-o-wine
Great evening stop for a couple of slices of pizza and wine in a can after a day of fly fishing at Camp Sherman.