Martolli’s uses only the freshest ingredients, and they prepare their dough and sauces fresh daily. Pizzas are hand-tossed in the traditional way and baked in old fashioned slate ovens. Visit the restaurant’s website for complete menu.
About Martolli’s Authentic Hand Tossed Pizza
Reviews & Ratings
-
July 26, 2026srebecekPizza with a Capital P
After a day of hiking we weren’t in the mood to go out to dinner. We ordered a pizza for take out and will give it a thumbs up. We ordered the medium sausage and roasted garlic option. First, the pizza was ready when promised. It stayed hot. The crust was tender with the right amount of crisp. The toppings were so generous we only ate 3 pieces total. Had the remainder as a leftover and with a quick visit to the oven it was like eating fresh baked pizza. We will order from there again.
-
July 25, 2026Gail C
Terrific pizza
The pizza was delicious—generous toppings made a small pizza perfect for 2 hungry adults! Friendly service made it even better!
-
July 1, 2026peterbJ9258RX
Saturday Night Pizza
Our group of seven had an absolutely lovely time here. The pizza was delicious, large sliced and was still great leftover the next day. Our server Alex was phenomenal. She looked after us so well and was the true highlight of our trip to Sisters!
-
August 17, 2025Quest14098581020
Fantastic pizza
This pizza was amazing, from the crust, to the sauce, to the topping! We ordered a half & half (sometimes hard to cook evenly) both sides were perfect. I highly recommend & we will return next time we are in town.
-
January 3, 2025Ben VGood pizza, mediocre service.
Good pizza, medium service. Tried to call in an order but were asked to hold. We sat on hold for ten minutes - I think we were probably forgotten about. We hung up as we pulled up to the restaurant and there was no orders in progress nor any other customers. Just three staff happily chatting. Pizza was pretty good though.