Hilltop House serves fresh, local seafood and the best aged Midwest beef. The menu boasts halibut, crab, and lobster as well as filet mignon, ribeye, and tender lamb. Voted BEST SEAFOOD ON THE COAST. And stunning views of the bay. Enjoy Happy Hour in their cozy lounge.
About Hilltop House
Reviews & Ratings
-
October 4, 2026Laurie PExcellent dining experience
Fantastic selection from appetizers to main dishes and dessert. Highly recommend for date night or family gathering. Quality of selections are more than worth the cost.
-
August 6, 2026Marie NI write for Food & Wine (and others) and I wont' touch this one, free meal or not!
After reading the reviews, not many from recent times mind you - I didn't like what I read. SO, view or now view, table cloths or not - I will eat elsewhere! You need to wash your hands people. Chef, go and talk to your customers! Period!
-
October 24, 2025Lon MUnfortunately, I will never be back.
I have been to the Hilltop numerous times. Not often but, numerous. I have always found the steaks to be the best in this area. Expensive, (hence not often) but I have always enjoyed the food. This evening, while waiting for our order, I witnessed one of the kitchen staff walk into the restroom while wearing black nitrile gloves. He walked out of the bathroom wearing black Nitrile gloves. Gloves in a professional kitchen are a single use item. To me this is more than concerning. A short time later, I witnessed the same employee walk to the bathroom again wearing black nitrile gloves and return from the bathroom wearing black nitrile gloves. Now, I am more than concerned about the quality of "ingredients" being served. I went into the bathroom just to make sure I wasn't over reacting and looked in the cabinet under the sink. No gloves. Not even an empty box. I walked out and asked to speak with the chef in charge. My plan was to talk quietly on the side and inform him of what I had seen. He apparently was too busy or didn't care and never came out of the kitchen. I wont be back. That's not what I'm looking for in the seasoning of my meal. Unbelievable, it's 2 months from 2026 and people still don't wash their hands after using the restroom.
-
September 2, 2024loriwaynes
Family dinner experience
Cant say enough good things about the service. We had tired kids and they really went the extra effort to keep everyone happy. Food was great too.
-
September 26, 2023JOANNE C
HORRIBLE
Food was REALLY BAD and service was even worse Instead of apologizing we got excuses Stay far far far away